Lomo'Instant Wide

Discussion in 'All Other Cameras' started by MoonMind, Jan 3, 2017.

  1. MoonMind

    MoonMind FF Veteran Subscribing Member

    278
    Mar 24, 2015
    Switzerland
    Matt
    full.

    M.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  2. MoonMind

    MoonMind FF Veteran Subscribing Member

    278
    Mar 24, 2015
    Switzerland
    Matt
    With the help of Google PhotoScan ...
    LIW_1 - Edited.

    M.
     
  3. kennethcooke

    kennethcooke FF Veteran

    276
    May 30, 2017
    Leeds, WestRiding, UK
  4. MoonMind

    MoonMind FF Veteran Subscribing Member

    278
    Mar 24, 2015
    Switzerland
    Matt
    I had already looked at this (I read The Phoblographer regularily - and of course, Chris linked to it) and wasn't that impressed by most of the blurb (including the image samples); after all, this is just the - stated - high-class execution of the simplest possible lens; f/8 hyperfocal isn't fantastic at all, it just means that I'd get a fixed focus lens that's not very useful for many genres of on-the-go photography. The gestalt and form factor are really, really nice, though; and the fact that it's a Tessar type lens (my favourite design of all times) is also very appealing for me. But all in all, I think it's pretty expensive for what you get - even if its optical quality is better than the heavily modded "instagrammatic" images are able to prove.

    In all honesty, my impression is that this thing is geared towards the hipster in-crowd, not photographers. That said, I'd be all over it if it were just a little brighter and had a means of focusing closer, maybe down to one meter. As it is, I'd probably not find a real use for it except for traveling as compact as possible; *anyone* could to hyperfocal with *any* lens, though most of them would probably be bigger. But then again, Voigtländer offer a couple of lenses that can do a lot(!) more than this Goerz 35mm - for instance, there's the tiny, yet beautifully made Ultron 40mm II SL for Nikon F (they seem to have discontinued the Canon EF version, however):

    40 mm / F 2,0 Ultron SL II N

    I own that lens, it's a great performer - and hardly any bigger; yes, it's more expensive, but you also get a lot more for your money!

    The same goes for mirrorless, including M mount - Voigtländer's Nokton Classic lenses are bright, small and beautiful, and while they have what is called "character" (really meaning visible optical limitations when not stopped down considerably), they're extremely well made and work fine (I own the 35mm):

    35 mm / F 1,4 Nokton
    40 mm / F 1,4 Nokton Classic

    If you need an even smaller lens (as small as the Goerz, yet full-featured!), the Color-Skopar pancake will serve you well:

    35 mm / F 2,5 Color Skopar Pancake II

    I know that all of these lenses are more expensive, but they are also a lot more useful. In short, considering what's already available, I don't think this lens is really worth my money. Besides, I already helped fund this:

    The Neptune Convertible Art Lens System

    Again, more expensive, but much more versatile, old-school - and fun (I know this kind of set lens from Zeiss Ikon Contaflex cameras I inherited from my father and grandfather).

    I'm prepared to eat my words once thorough (field) testing with this lens has been done and results are convincing. For the time being, I'll stay away from it.

    M.
     
  5. kennethcooke

    kennethcooke FF Veteran

    276
    May 30, 2017
    Leeds, WestRiding, UK
    I think I am in agreement Matt, when I got the a7R II I ordered a Zeiss Sonnar 35mm f2.8 E-Mount lens which seems very good and gets rave reviews however because it has no aperture ring using hyper-focal focusing is not possible, a feature that I used regularly on my Leica M Summicron 35mm asph but I was advised by the dealer that I bought the Sony body from that the Summicron 35mm asph would not align with the sensor of the Sony and he suggested me keeping my 50mm Summicron and trading in my 35mm
     
  6. MoonMind

    MoonMind FF Veteran Subscribing Member

    278
    Mar 24, 2015
    Switzerland
    Matt
    I think (but I may be mistaken) that there are actually lists available for hyperfocal distances, so far, I haven't bothered to look ... Anyhow, I hope you have fun with the well received Sony Zeiss 35mm; I'm not sure I'd have traded in the 35mm 'cron, though, but that's probably me (I'm really bad a trading in things I've grown to like - even if I have access to "better" alternatives). Again, have fun - I think you'll find the Zeiss very usable, and since it's said to AF fairly quickly, I think you won't miss hyperfocal distances that much. Hyperfocal was/is a crutch - a very useful one, but still a crutch.

    M.
     
  7. kennethcooke

    kennethcooke FF Veteran

    276
    May 30, 2017
    Leeds, WestRiding, UK
    You may be right, and, yes it was quite a wrench to trade the 35 Summicron in as it was my most used lens but when I discussed it with the dealer he said that it was not compatible with the Sony Alpha camera. Something to do with the distance between the rear lens distance and the sensor, and I guess he had no reason to give me false information. I just said that as part of the deal I needed to trade in one of my M6's and either my 35 or 50 Summicron.
     
  8. MoonMind

    MoonMind FF Veteran Subscribing Member

    278
    Mar 24, 2015
    Switzerland
    Matt
    I see - makes sense. The Sony Zeiss is no slouch - you'll be fine, I think. And you still have your 50mm 'cron - wonderful lens. I own it as well; though because of my perference for Tessar type lenses, I use the collapsible Elmar f/2.8 a bit more often. But it's one of the two benchmark 50mm lenses I own, and it's the one that has more character (the other one is the hulking Sigma 50mm f/1.4 Art - great lens, but definitely not recommended as a walk-around companion; the 50mm Summicron, on the other hand, fits that slots exceedingly well).

    M.
     
  9. kennethcooke

    kennethcooke FF Veteran

    276
    May 30, 2017
    Leeds, WestRiding, UK
    I agree Matt, by the by, I really love the panoramic work that the guys do on this public Facebook page. I am not saying I wish to go down this line but their work is very attractive

    Log into Facebook | Facebook
     
    Last edited: Jul 17, 2017
Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
Lomography Lomo'Instant Automat Glass All Other Cameras May 3, 2017
Lomo'Instant All Other Cameras Nov 19, 2016